Remembering Chosin

Marines at Chosin
Marines at Chosin
Marines at Chosin

It's a pivotal event of the 20th century. An experience so monumental that it has come to represent, even encapsulate, the ongoing struggle between the forces of oppression, tyranny, and authoritarianism and those who believe in freedom, justice, and democracy. The Chosin Campaign, correctly called “Changjin" in Korea, was a defining moment in history.

The two-week long battle, pitting approximately 30,000 US, ROK, and British troops against 120,000 Chinese soldiers, occurred in the worst of conditions: excruciatingly cold weather, brutal terrain, and deadly isolation.

The snow, ice, wind, and below-zero temperatures, combined with towering mountains, plunging cliffs, and treacherous roads, were perfect for a Himalayan mountain-climbing movie set. Not a battlefield.

The conditions at Changjin were so bad that Oliver P. Smith, the commanding general of 1st Marine Division-the largest unit at the Reservoir and the one that did the most fighting-said it was “never intended for military operations.” Anyone who fought there would agree.

But the Chinese were the real enemy. The disciplined, courageous, and seemingly tireless Chinese soldiers were everywhere. The 1st Marine Division, surrounded and vastly outnumbered, was in one of the most precarious and potentially disastrous predicaments of any unit in Marine Corps history, arguably in American history.

Through herculean efforts, exceptional war-fighting skills, and countless acts of valor, the Marines broke out of the trap and made their way to Hungnam, a North Korean port on the East Sea. By the end of December 1950, 105,000 servicemen and 100,000 North Korean refugees had been evacuated in one of America's largest sea-borne withdrawals. Mao’s boast that the 1st Marine Division would be annihilated in “only a matter of time” had backfired. It was the last time the Chinese leader would ever threaten to obliterate a US Marine unit.

invitation from MPVA

An invitation from the Ministry of Patriots and Veterans Affairs

Yesterday, I was privileged to participate in an event honoring the brave men who fought at Changjin. The ceremony, held at Seoul National Cemetery, was a moving tribute to the Marines, soldiers, airmen, and sailors who suffered, sacrificed, and died in the remote mountains of North Korea.

Pi Woo-jin, the ROK's Minister of Patriots and Veterans Affairs (comparable to the US Veterans Administration) attended the ceremony, and on behalf of ROK President Moon Jae-in, thanked the Changjin veterans for their sacrifices. President Moon has a personal connection to the campaign. His parents were North Korean refugees and were rescued during the Hungnam Evacuation.

I also heard Major General James W. Lukeman, Commander of US Marine Corps Forces Korea, give a heartfelt and powerful address on the Changjin Battle’s significance to the Republic of Korea, the United States, and the US Marine Corps. Echoing the words of President Moon in his speech this summer at The National Museum of the Marine Corps, Gen. Lukeman reminded the nearly 10,000 attendees that without the sacrifices made at Changjin and Hungnam, the lives of 100,000 refugees-and South Korea’s freedom-would have almost certainly been lost.

Especially memorable for me was the recognition given to my grandfather, Colonel Edward H. Forney, USMC, the evacuation control officer at Hungnam. Col. Forney was recognized for the part he played in rescuing the refugees, and I was honored to represent our family at the event.

I’m thankful for the MPVA and the Korea Military Merit Awardees Association (KMMAA) for organizing the ceremony and for Mr. John Lee, a Changjin veteran and interpreter for 1st Marine Division, for inviting me. Looking back on the afternoon, I feel privileged to have been part of the special occasion.

From Lee Gyeong-pil's ("Kimchi 5") emotional letter of appreciation to those who participated in the Changjin Battle and Hungnam Evacuation, to talking with Mr. Jean White, a US Marine Changjin veteran and president of the Chosin Few, the observance was an outstanding tribute to truly outstanding men.

Semper Fi!


Speakers at the ceremony
Lee Gyeong-pil ("Kimchi 5") reads an emotional letter of appreciation to Chosin (Changjin) veterans. On the stage with him is Jean White.
Minister of Patriots and Veterans Affairs
Pi Woo-Jin, Minister of Patriots and Veterans Affairs (MPVA), with ROK Marine Corps Commandant Sang-hoon Lee before the ceremony
Major General James W. Lukeman, Commander of US Marine Corps Forces Korea, with Jean White, Chosin veteran
Major General James W. Lukeman, Commander of US Marine Corps Forces Korea, with Jean White, Chosin veteran
Moon Jae-in at Chosin Memorial
ROK President Moon Jae-in delivering his speech at the Chosin Memorial in Quantico, Virginia
Ned with Chosin veterans
Ned with Jean White (center)-a US Marine Chosin veteran and president of the Chosin Few- and John Lee- also a Chosin veteran and interpreter for the 1st Marine Division
Honoring Chosin veterans-stage and ceremony
Honoring Marine Corps veterans of Chosin (Changjin) Campaign

Top photos: Marines at Chosin: Their eyes say it all. (Photo Credit: This is War! David Douglas Duncan)


  1. Melvin B Echelberger on October 30, 2017 at 1:43 am

    I had the sad but truly the honored duty of being a Navy Corpsman to a lot of the Marine HEROES that were wounded/frozen from Chosin November-December 1950. I was the transport Corpsman from AFB Travis Ward C to Oak Knoll Naval Hospital Oakland, CA

    • Ned Forney on October 30, 2017 at 7:56 am

      I can’t imagine what you saw. As an infantry officer in the Marine Corps, I know first hand the important role Corpsmen play in the Marine mission. “Corpsman Up!”
      Thank you for sharing your story and for serving, Mr. Echelberger.